Open letter to Kofi Annan
A letter to UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, from the archive — on why the Security Council reforms left the Arab world, and the global south, without a permanent seat.
By Ajit Kumar Jha ·

Editor's note: This open letter by the Editor of Oman Tribune (now NDTV) Ajit Kumar Jha is drawn from his personal archive, written around 2005 during his years in Oman, as part of the Indian diaspora there. It replies to an essay — "Is preventive war aggression?" — that United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan had written at the time. Mr Jha has shared it with Diaspora Dreams for republication. It is reproduced as written; its references — to the Iraq war, the Security Council reform panel and the oil-for-food inquiry — belong to the moment it was written.
Dear Mr Kofi Annan,
I must begin by thanking you for your perceptive piece, "Is preventive war aggression?", that you wrote exclusively for us (December 2004). I appreciate your concerns and share the anguish that you expressed with regard to world security. I completely agree with you that making this world more secure is indeed a shared responsibility, as well as a shared interest.
I appreciate the time you took off your busy schedule to write for us on this crucial subject, displaying openness, candidness and rare insight.
However, let me now touch upon where I disagree with you. Although I am not a pessimist, yet unlike you — who seems to think that the United Nations has become stronger compared to what it was years ago — I firmly believe that the world's highest body is not only becoming toothless but is today in the grip of a crisis of gigantic proportions: the crisis of legitimacy.
The UN's sorry state of affairs became painfully obvious to one and all during the ongoing war in Iraq. Displaying total indifference to any suggestions by the UN, the United States under George Bush Jr's presidentship, in a purely unilateralist fashion, decided to launch an attack on Iraq. The UN body, despite its all-powerful Security Council Resolution 1441 arming it with tremendous powers, stood by helplessly as close to over 100,000 civilians got killed and an even higher number maimed in a senseless war. Never in its history has the UN looked so ineffective.
The irony is that even those who supported the Iraq war in the name of making the world safer from the threat of terrorism are equally furious with the UN for not agreeing to act. They believe that the UN simply refused to disarm Saddam Hussein when it could have done so, despite a clutch of Security Council resolutions, including the powers of threatening serious consequences if Iraq did not comply with international standards of disarmament. Pontificating in the typical UN style for close to a decade, those in favour of war believe the UN simply could not bring itself to act. In short, both supporters as well as detractors of the UN mutually agree that the global body has simply become irrelevant.
I presume that, perhaps recognising the danger of such irrelevance, you must have hit upon the idea of the 16-member panel of experts. In your words, "the distinguished men and women from all parts of the world and from different fields of expertise" have come up with the 101 recommendations that you believe are the "most comprehensive and coherent set of proposals for forging a common response to common threats." I do wish, purely for purposes of democracy and accountability, that the 16-member expert panel was not appointed but elected by some transparent mechanism. Also, one wonders what is the representative character of such an expert panel? Does it cover all geographic regions of the world?
Sir, you might wonder why I am raising questions on representation. Let me assure you that I do not doubt your intentions nor, for that matter, your competence. I have full faith in your spectacular abilities and those of your experts. The honest and simple answer is that I am raising the issue of representation because I firmly believe that the Security Council is an unrepresentative relic, through no fault of yours.
Consider the composition of the Security Council: of its 15 seats, 10 are occupied by temporary members, which rotate every two years and have no veto powers; five are permanent veto-wielding members — the US, the UK, France, Russia and China. Other than China, the four are essentially Western powers of the developed world. China is the lone member of the numerically strong, but economically poor, developing world to which you and I both belong. None from the vast continents of Africa, Latin America or Asia, other than China, was considered important enough to be a permanent member of such an august council. No doubt, the council's composition raises questions of representation.
The structure of the Security Council is nothing else but a throwback to the world order immediately following the Second World War. Only victors were given membership, but no place either for the vanquished or for the laity from the poor third world. Even China's inclusion was an after-thought. The jungle law of "might is right" seemed to have guided the choice of membership. So much for justice, fairness and representation in the world's highest body and its most august chamber!
The institutional recommendations by the expert panel set up by you seem to have proposed two alternatives. According to alternative number one, six countries — Germany, Japan, India, Brazil and two African countries (possibly South Africa and Nigeria) — are to secure permanent seats without a veto. Together with this, three extra non-permanent members would end up taking the total number of Security Council members to 24. According to the second alternative, the Security Council would expand its membership to 24 by creating a new middle tier of members who would serve for a tenure of four years and could be consecutively re-elected. The temporary two-year membership will continue, the difference being they cannot be consecutively re-elected.
Both sets of alternatives are better than the status quo. However, both continue to be inadequate for various reasons. First, what is the use of becoming a permanent member without a veto power? Instead of reforming the Security Council, such a move will only continue to maintain the exclusive privileges of the Big Five. Second, let me simply raise one fundamental objection, the one I think will pose a serious challenge to any structural change in the council. Simply take a look at the UN peacekeeping operations, the map of which we ran along with your piece. The majority of the 16 current peacekeeping operations are concentrated in two regions of the world: the Middle East and North Africa, the two hot spots of the world. Yet, your expert panel quietly forgot to recommend any permanent seats on the Security Council from these two regions of the globe, which between them occupy the political centre of gravity of the world.
Moreover, if culture and religion are taken as criteria for representation other than geography, then the entire Arab world — and surely the countries whose predominant religion is the fastest growing one of the world, Islam — find no representation in the newly proposed Security Council. How does your expert panel think of bringing any semblance of legitimacy and credibility back to the UN Security Council if the most troubled regions are omitted from the new power structure?
Similarly, the expert panel report urges the UN to make better use of its assets in the war against terrorism. One of the central problems with such a counter-terrorism strategy is the inability of UN member states to define what constitutes terrorism. Your expert panel's suggestion that terrorism is "any action that is intended to cause death or serious bodily damage to civilians or non-combatants" may be a necessary condition defining terrorism, but surely not sufficient. The important issue of "foreign occupation of one's lands" as constituting an act of terror is not even being considered. After all, as you point out, the expert panel offered "a clear explanation and reaffirmation of the right of self-defence." That must include the right of self-defence against foreign occupation. Without the inclusion of such a right, the entire Third World would not have been free today from the yoke of colonialism.
Moreover, the UN has recently been dogged by allegations of corruption. The UN's $62 billion "oil-for-food" programme that allowed Iraq to sell oil to pay for essential goods as a humanitarian consideration is, according to media reports, laced with scandals. Former Iraqi president Saddam Hussein, it is alleged, was one of the main beneficiaries of this scam. The American newspaper, the New York Sun, reports that Kojo Annan, your son, who worked for Cotecna, a firm that inspected goods at the border crossings, may have been involved in the scam. There have been demands from various quarters that you must resign. Although US President George Bush has not categorically asked for your resignation, he has asked for a "full and open accounting" of the UN oil-for-food programme. Given the fact that US taxpayers pay for the UN programme (although the US is the largest defaulter), just like other taxpayers do, the President is well within his rights to ask for such a probe.
Under such black clouds of suspicion and scandal, and given such a grave turn of events, I wonder what will be the fate of the UN reforms that you have initiated. I hope none of these accusations are true, and none of them stand up to scrutiny in a court of law. However, given the fact that in an increasingly unipolar world the US is clearly not in a mood to cooperate with the UN, the fate of the UN reforms is surely in the doldrums. I agree with you that making this world secure is a shared responsibility as well as a shared interest. But given the state of the world's highest body and its increasing marginalisation in this unipolar world, how will one ensure that each member of the world shares that responsibility and interest?






